Biggest Problems With Synthetic Roof Underlayment
|

10 Biggest Problems With Synthetic Roof Underlayment

Synthetic roof underlayment is a manmade moisture barrier installed between the roof deck and the roofing material, such as metal, tile, or asphalt shingles. It’s made from laminated polypropylene or polyethylene, which are advanced polymers. Synthetic underlayment is used in place of traditional felt underlayment.

It’s popular for its durability, light weight, and water resistance, especially in hurricane-prone areas like Florida. But despite the benefits, it comes with some downsides. Familiarity with the biggest problems with synthetic roof underlayment and how to avoid them will help you prevent costly damage to your roof.

1. Wrinkles, Tears, or Slips From Improper Installation

Poor installation (which is one of the most common roofing mistakes) leads to ripples, loose spots from slipping, or tears, especially in Florida’s heat and humidity. These mistakes leave your roof vulnerable to leaks and early failure. Unless you have roofing experience, hire a licensed professional roofer who knows how to secure synthetic underlayment flat and tight.

Common installation mistakes that lead to problems:

  • Overstretching the material across the deck causes ripples and tears.
  • Using the wrong fastener or spacing leads to pull-through or blow-offs.
  • Ignoring manufacturer guidelines by not using their approved seam tape creates water pathways at overlaps.
  • Working in wet or windy conditions during a roof replacement or new roof installation without edge restraint lets the corners flap and tear.

2. Moisture Trapping Without Proper Ventilation

Synthetic underlayment blocks water but also traps vapor beneath the roof deck. Trapped moisture leads to mold growth, wood rot, and damaged insulation.

Prevent this by installing a full ventilation system, including ridge vents, soffit vents, gable vents, and/or attic fans, to keep air flowing and moisture moving out. In some cases, a breathable synthetic underlayment may help reduce vapor buildup, but proper venting is still essential.

3. UV Exposure Degrades the Underlayment

Prolonged UV exposure breaks down the surface layer of synthetic underlayment. In Florida, storms often delay roofing jobs for weeks, and even UV-rated products start to fail with too much sun. Choose underlayments rated for at least 90 to 180 days of UV protection.

When shingles, tiles, or metal panels get torn off in a storm, the underlayment is exposed to the intense sun. UV rays weaken it fast, especially in high-heat zones. Always inspect your roof after storms to catch damage early, and have it repaired promptly.

4. Loss of VOCs and Material Breakdown

Some synthetic roof underlayments release volatile organic compounds (VOCs) as they age. Florida’s heat speeds up this breakdown, triggering chemical changes that cause brittleness, shrinkage, or adhesive failure.

When VOCs leach out, the underlayment loses flexibility and water resistance. Always choose underlayment products tested for VOC stability and long-term high-heat performance.

5. Cracking or Blistering in Extreme Temperatures

Synthetic membrane layers expand and contract in hot and cold weather. In Florida’s scorching summers or sudden cold snaps, low-quality underlayments will crack or form blisters.

These failures break the moisture barrier and let water reach the roof deck. Choose products rated for wide temperature swings and proven to resist thermal cycling over time.

6. Slippery Surface Risks for Installers

Some synthetic underlayments have slick surfaces that become dangerous when wet from rain or dew. Slips and falls slow down the installation process and increase the chance of underlayment that is improperly fastened, loose, or wrinkled.

Choose underlayment with a textured or grippy surface to improve footing during installation. And consider letting a professional handle the job because the CDC reports that over 97% of roofing-related falls happen at home, often during DIY repairs. Hiring an experienced roofer helps avoid serious injuries and ensures proper installation.

7. Incompatibility With Certain Roofing Systems

Not all synthetic roof underlayments work with every roofing material. Using the wrong product under metal roof panels, tile, or specialty shingles can void your roof warranty or cause premature failure.

Always verify compatibility with your roofing contractor and choose underlayment that’s approved for your roof type and local building codes.

8. Misleading Thickness Claims

Some synthetic underlayment brands pad their specs by including the fuzzy top layer in the measurement. While this feature improves walkability, it doesn’t mean the membrane itself is thick and durable. That “mil thickness” number can be misleading.

Instead, check the weight per square (100 square feet). Heavier underlayments have a stronger membrane layer, which is what truly protects your roof. Weight gives a better picture of the underlayment’s waterproofing and tear resistance.

9. Some Synthetics Just Don’t Hold Up

Low-cost synthetic underlayments often cut corners on material weight, UV protection, and adhesion. Some may delaminate, peeling apart at the layers, and lose their water barrier entirely.

Watch for these red flags:

  • Products with no testing or performance certifications
  • A big-box store deal with no warranty or contractor backing
  • Super thin sheets that rip or tear easily during installation
  • Underlayment that curls at the edges before the installation is complete

Choose a code-compliant product from a trusted manufacturer to ensure long-term protection and performance in Florida’s climate.

10. Higher Upfront Cost Than Felt Roof Underlayment

Synthetic roof underlayment costs more per square foot than asphalt felt. Using synthetic underlayment will increase the cost of a new roof replacement.

Weigh the long-term benefits of synthetic underlayment, such as better durability, longer lifespan, and fewer repairs, against the upfront expense. Decide if this investment fits your home and budget.

Best Practices for Synthetic Roof Underlayment

These best practices will help your synthetic underlayment remain a long-lasting, reliable barrier for your home.

  • Choose a high-quality underlayment rated for your local climate and roof type.
  • For coastal homes, look for high-heat, salt-resistant membranes.
  • For metal roofs in coastal areas, select products with enhanced corrosion resistance to prevent fastener degradation.
  • Ask your contractor about “breathable” options that balance moisture protection with vapor escape.
  • Ensure proper installation by a qualified professional following the manufacturer’s guidelines.
  • After hurricanes or severe storms, inspect your roof for damage using our Roof Damage Assessment Checklist.
  • Schedule roof inspections every year to catch early delamination, wrinkles, or UV damage. In Florida, it’s also important to inspect after the rainy season and again before the peak summer sun.

Don’t Let Underlayment Be the Weak Link

Synthetic roof underlayment offers a superior moisture protective barrier and durability when high-quality material is chosen and installed correctly. Understanding and avoiding potential pitfalls, like installation challenges, UV damage, and moisture trapping, helps prevent costly repairs down the road.

Work with a qualified local roofing contractor who matches the underlayment to your roof type and climate. Ensure your roofing material is installed promptly after the underlayment. Regular inspections will ensure your synthetic underlayment continues to be a reliable, long-lasting barrier for your home.

Similar Posts